Square vs Shopify POS for a Small Retail Store: Which Costs Less?

Square vs Shopify POS for a Small Retail Store: Which Costs Less?

For a small retail store, Shopify POS usually costs slightly less than Square once card sales pass about $15,600 a month, because its lower per-transaction fee outweighs its monthly subscription. Below that volume, Square costs less, because it charges no monthly fee at all. The deciding factor for square vs shopify pos for small retail store cost is therefore your monthly transaction count, not the headline subscription price.

The details matter, because the two systems charge you in completely different ways. Square makes its money almost entirely on card fees. Shopify charges a monthly plan fee first, then a slightly lower card fee. This guide gives you the exact model to run both on your own sales numbers.

What does each POS system actually charge?

Square POS has no monthly fee for its basic point-of-sale app. You pay per card transaction — for in-person payments, around 2.6% plus 15 cents per transaction at the time of writing. Hardware is separate: a mobile reader starts at around $49, a counter terminal at around $299, and a full register setup at around $799. A small shop can genuinely run on the free plan.

Shopify POS works the other way round. You need a Shopify plan to use it at all — the entry plan runs around $39 a month — and that includes POS Lite, the basic till app. POS Pro, which adds staff permissions, smart inventory, and deeper reporting, adds around $89 a month per location. In-person card fees through Shopify Payments run around 2.6% plus 10 cents per transaction on the entry plan. Hardware is again separate, running into the low hundreds of dollars.

Notice the five-cent gap. Five cents sounds trivial until you multiply it by a thousand transactions a month.

How much would each cost on $20,000 a month in card sales?

Take a typical small retail shop: $20,000 a month in card sales, spread over 1,000 transactions, an average sale of $20. Rates change, so re-check both pricing pages before you sign — but the shape of the result holds even if a rate moves a few cents.

Square, free plan: 2.6% of $20,000 is $520, plus 15 cents times 1,000 transactions is $150. Total card fees: $670 a month. Monthly subscription: $0. Total: $670 a month.

Shopify POS Lite: 2.6% of $20,000 is $520, plus 10 cents times 1,000 transactions is $100. Total card fees: $620 a month. Monthly subscription: about $39 for the entry Shopify plan. Total: about $659 a month.

Shopify POS Pro: the same $620 in card fees, plus about $39 for the plan and about $89 for POS Pro. Total: about $748 a month.

So on this volume, Shopify POS Lite edges out Square by about $11 a month, and Shopify POS Pro costs about $78 a month more than Square. The two are close, and the Pro upgrade — not the card rate — is what makes Shopify the expensive option.

At what sales volume does Shopify POS become cheaper?

The crossover is where Shopify's five-cents-per-transaction saving covers its $39 monthly plan: $39 divided by $0.05 is 780 transactions a month, or about $15,600 at a $20 average sale.

Below 780 transactions a month, Square is cheaper, and the gap widens as volume falls — a shop doing 300 transactions a month pays roughly $24 a month less on Square. Above 780, Shopify Lite pulls ahead by $5 for every 100 extra transactions. At 2,000 transactions a month, Shopify Lite is about $61 a month cheaper than Square.

This is why asking "which POS is cheaper?" without your transaction count is meaningless. A quiet gift shop and a busy convenience store can get opposite answers from the same two pricing pages. Count last month's card transactions and find your side of 780.

What else costs money that the pricing pages hide?

Monthly fees and card rates are only the visible part of the bill. Three hidden costs change the comparison for real shops.

First, hardware. Both systems need a card reader, and most shops want a tablet stand, a barcode scanner, and a receipt printer. Budget a few hundred dollars either way, and buy from the vendor's approved list — an unsupported reader that fails on a Saturday afternoon costs far more than the saving.

Second, payment lock-in. Square processes your payments itself, so there is no choice to make. Shopify gives its best card rates only through Shopify Payments; use an outside processor and Shopify adds an extra transaction fee on top, which can wipe out the five-cent advantage entirely.

Third, the online-store question. Shopify POS shares products, stock, and customer records with a Shopify website, so a shop that already sells online gets one inventory instead of two. But if you do not sell online, Shopify's $39 plan is a fee you pay for a website you may never build.

Which one fits which kind of small retail store?

Choose Square if you are a counter-only shop, or a new shop under about $15,000 a month in card sales. No monthly fee, cheap hardware, and a till your staff learn in an afternoon. Its inventory tools cover a few hundred products well; once you need purchase orders and multi-location stock, you will outgrow the free plan.

Choose Shopify POS Lite if you already sell on Shopify, or you process more than about 780 card transactions a month. The shared inventory alone can justify it for an online-plus-store shop, and the lower per-transaction fee pays for the plan once you cross the crossover volume.

Choose Shopify POS Pro only if you need what it adds. Staff permissions, detailed reporting, and smart inventory suit a shop with several staff or a second location — but at about $89 a month per location, it turns Shopify from the cheaper option into the dearer one on typical small-shop volumes. Do not buy Pro for features you might use one day.

How to run this comparison on your own numbers

Take last month's card statement and note two numbers: total card sales and total card transactions. Then work out:

  1. Square: 2.6% of card sales, plus 15 cents per transaction. No monthly fee.
  2. Shopify POS Lite: 2.6% of card sales, plus 10 cents per transaction, plus about $39.
  3. Shopify POS Pro: the Lite figure, plus about $89 per location.

Whichever total is lowest is your cheaper till. Re-run it if your sales double or you open a second till, because growth alone can flip the answer at 780 transactions a month.

The bottom line for a small retail store

For a small retail store, square vs shopify pos for small retail store cost comes down to transaction count. Under about 780 card transactions a month, Square costs less because it charges no subscription. Above that, Shopify POS Lite costs less because its lower per-transaction fee covers its plan. Shopify POS Pro costs more than either on typical small-shop volumes, and is worth it only for the staff and inventory features it adds. Run the three-line calculation on your own last month before you buy, and let the numbers — not the pricing page headline — decide.

Square vs Shopify POS at a Glance

Item Square Shopify POS
Monthly fee $0 About $39 for the entry Shopify plan (POS Lite included); POS Pro adds about $89 per location
In-person card fee Around 2.6% + 15 cents per transaction Around 2.6% + 10 cents per transaction
Cost on $20,000 a month / 1,000 transactions $670 a month Lite about $659 a month; Pro about $748 a month
Crossover point Cheaper below 780 transactions a month Lite pulls ahead above 780 transactions a month (about $15,600 at a $20 average sale), by $5 for every 100 extra transactions
Hidden costs Hardware a few hundred dollars; no payment choice (Square processes payments itself) Hardware a few hundred dollars; best rates only through Shopify Payments, and the $39 plan pays for a website you may never build if you do not sell online
Best fit Counter-only or new shop under about $15,000 a month in card sales Lite if you already sell on Shopify or pass 780 transactions a month; Pro only if you need staff permissions, detailed reporting or smart inventory

Related reading: how to pick a POS system for a small retail shop, best inventory management software for a small business, and best payroll software for a business with under 10 employees.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Square or Shopify POS cheaper for a small shop?

It depends on transaction volume. Square charges no monthly fee, so it is cheaper below about 780 card transactions a month (roughly $15,600 at a $20 average sale). Above that volume, Shopify POS Lite becomes cheaper because its per-transaction fee is about five cents lower, which covers its monthly plan fee.

Does Shopify POS require a Shopify website?

You need a Shopify plan to use Shopify POS, which includes an online store, but you are not forced to sell online. The plan fee applies even if you only sell in person, so a counter-only shop should weigh that $39 a month against the card-fee saving.

What is the difference between Shopify POS Lite and POS Pro?

POS Lite is the basic till included with a Shopify plan: sales, payments, and shared inventory. POS Pro adds staff permissions, advanced inventory and reporting, and customer management tools, at about $89 a month per location. Most single-location small shops do not need Pro.

Can I switch from Square to Shopify POS later?

Yes. Export your product list, customer list, and stock counts from Square before cancelling anything, import them into Shopify, and run both tills side by side for a week on quiet days before switching fully.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *